Compass Insurance Group started in 2007 to serve the needs of the senior community.  The group’s founder, Gary Nolley, realized the market was under-served and knew that the Medicare process was challenging for many individuals.  With so many products and companies out there, the decision-making process is often overwhelming.

Gary set out to address those needs and his commitment and knowledge has been instilled in all the agents at Compass.  Compass’ strives to ensure its clients are informed and knowledgeable about the products which they buy – both before and after the purchase.

Compass also represents companies and products of the traditional insurance and annuity variety.  Many of our agents started in these markets before joining Compass, so their knowledge and experience in these areas is immense.

No matter the products you are in the market for, Compass is here for you – helping you navigate the insurance maze.

Comments are closed.

  • About Us

    Compass Insurance Group is a family-owned insurance agency specializing in products for seniors. Our agents are well-educated and experienced in Medicare and Medicare alternatives, including prescription drug plans, Medicare Supplements and Advantage plans.
  • Reach Out

    103 West Boggstown Road
    Shelbyville, IN 46176
    Phone: 317.398.9321